Back in September, I examined the relationship between home prices and mortgage rates using data from the St. Louis Fed's FRED database. By rebasing both the S&P Case-Shiller U.S. National Home Price Index and the 30-Year Fixed Rate Mortgage Average to the same starting point in February 2016, I observed a clear pattern: home prices rose steadily for years while mortgage rates remained historically low, but once rates surged in 2022, home-price appreciation largely stalled.
At the time, I argued that the key dynamic in the housing market was not necessarily falling home prices, but rather an affordability shock. Mortgage rates had risen sharply, limiting demand, while housing supply remained too constrained to allow prices to correct meaningfully on a national basis.
A recent article published in ZeroHedge (ZH) titled, HousingCrisis Escalates: Pending Home Sales Hit Record Low, Building Permits WorstSince COVID As Homebuilder Confidence Crashes, suggests that the dynamic I explained back in September has continued to intensify.
The ZH article mentioned that pending home sales recently fell to a record low, declining more than 17% from a year earlier. Building permits dropped sharply (7.4% month-over-month), homebuilder confidence weakened considerably (weakest reading since 2012), and single-family permit activity fell to levels last seen during the COVID period. While home prices appear to have remained relatively resilient, housing activity itself appears to be slowing significantly.
This last distinction is important because housing corrections do not always begin with falling prices. Often, they begin with declining transaction volumes, weaker construction activity, deteriorating builder sentiment, shrinking affordability, and a growing disconnect between what buyers can afford and what sellers are willing to accept. In many cases, activity declines first while prices remain relatively stable. In other words, the market freezes before it falls.
One of the most important factors contributing to this environment is what has become known as the mortgage lock-in effect. Many existing homeowners refinanced or purchased homes when mortgage rates were near historic lows. Today, the average mortgage held by existing homeowners remains far below current market rates. As the ZH stated, “the gap between current mortgage rates (above 7%) and the average mortgage across all of American homeowners (4.36%) is extreme to say the least.” As a result, homeowners have little incentive to sell, since doing so would likely require replacing an existing low-rate mortgage with one carrying substantially higher borrowing costs.
The result is a housing market caught between two opposing forces. On one hand, prospective buyers are increasingly constrained by affordability challenges. On the other hand, existing homeowners are reluctant to sell, limiting inventory and helping support home prices. The outcome is a market characterized by fewer transactions rather than widespread price declines. This observation reinforces the framework I outlined in September.
My first scenario envisioned mortgage rates remaining elevated or moving modestly higher, resulting in a prolonged period of flat national home prices with localized declines. The recent collapse in housing activity appears broadly consistent with that outcome.
My second scenario anticipated sharper rate increases leading to mild national price declines as affordability deteriorated further. While there is evidence that demand continues to weaken, the supply side remains sufficiently constrained that meaningful national price declines have yet to materialize.
My third scenario contemplated a combination of elevated rates and rising unemployment. This remains the scenario I am watching most closely.
Mortgage rates alone can reduce transaction activity, weaken construction, and depress demand. However, significant nationwide home-price declines typically require a second catalyst: labor-market deterioration. If unemployment rises meaningfully during a recession, forced selling could increase at the same time that affordability remains challenged. Under those conditions, the housing market would likely face much stronger downward pressure on prices.
I continue to believe that a recession is a likely outcome over the next 6 to 12 months. If that assessment proves correct, the housing market may eventually transition from an affordability-driven slowdown to a broader price adjustment.
Conclusion
The latest housing data appears to support the view that rising mortgage rates are freezing the housing market rather than breaking it. The key question going forward is whether the economy remains strong enough to sustain that equilibrium, or whether a recession and rising unemployment eventually transform a housing slowdown into a more meaningful housing correction.
No comments:
Post a Comment